Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
The strangest and most memorable interaction I had with ChatGPT Atlas happened while I was scrolling Bluesky She asked him to highlight any trends she sees. (ChatGPT lists “political anxiety” and “everyday absurdity” as two of the trends in my timeline.) I was curious what would happen if I opened my Bluesky direct messages, which were a few old messages from friends. So I asked the bot what it would see if I opened that most private page.
“Opening your DMs won’t reveal anything to me — I’ll simply stop ‘seeing’ the page until it returns to public view (such as a feed, profile, or post),” read part of ChatGPT’s answer.
Knowing that my Bluesky DMs didn’t contain anything sensitive, I experimented. Although the bot said it would not “see the message list, conversation text, or sender information,” that was not the case.
I opened a direct message inviting me to an event, then asked the bot a follow-up question asking about the message and what the invitation was about. You’ve received a response from ChatGPT with facts from the conversation, as well as details about the sender. What does it give? I asked the robot to explain itself, just to see if it would back down privacy Claims I made earlier in the chat.
“I don’t have access to your private messages or account data unless you paste this text or explicitly show it to me in the chat,” read ChatGPT’s response. “What you just did — asking ‘What is this invitation for?’ — temporarily popped up part of the context of the message so I could answer your question. But I have no background or insight into your inbox other than you’re actively adding to our conversation.”
The first answer provided by the Ask ChatGPT sidebar is a possible example of an AI “hallucination,” also known as a bug, which is common during interactions with generative AI tools. The second is More harmonious With how the tool actually works.
While some users may appreciate the presence of… chatbot Always pulled to the side of their screen, ready to highlight relevant facts or summarize details, it seemed like an unreliable tour guide to me. The one who was overly confident in his cute responses and took up too much space.
I’ll continue to test Atlas as my main browser over the next few weeks, but for now, I’ll leave this sidebar off. I prefer the full screen online version.
