Count the wake of Renaissance Rome with the Meta Ray-Ban screen

This is it Mohsena weekly newsletter sent every Friday from one of the Verge’s top reviewers Victoria song Which analyzes and discusses the latest phones, smartwatches, apps and other gadgets that you swear will change your life. Mohsen It arrives in our subscribers’ inboxes at 10 a.m. ET. Subscribe to Mohsen here.

It is a universally acknowledged fact that lovers of art history in Rome should see the Sistine Chapel. Less recognized is that Get Getting there from the Vatican Museum would probably take longer than Frodo Baggins’ entire journey to Mordor.

Ostensibly, a well-equipped art lover might have a handy audio guide, or at least, to help pass the roughly two to three hours it takes to wander past countless busts of nude marble men and Greek amphorae. I was no Well prepared. My family’s tickets were purchased last minute. I drew the short stick with a self-guided solo tour during one of the last periods of the day.

All I have is a pair of Meta Ray-Ban Display Glasses, an international data plan from T-Mobile, and an iPhone 17 that’s running on dangerously low battery. Imagine my surprise when I already had it great time.

Twenty-five days ago, I arrived in Italy like a crust. Technically, the vacation has begun. Work done, bags packed, cat sitters arranged, I should be able to relax. Instead, I spent the nearly eight-hour flight to Rome thinking about my then-newly published book Meta Ray Ban review And the simple existential crisis it provoked.

In short, the glasses were an impressive piece of engineering. I felt conflicted about the privacy and cultural questions they raised while using them in my daily life, as well genuine Opportunities That technology promised. I was curious to see how well the live translation feature of the glasses worked. Once I arrived in Rome, the glasses came out.

Ironically, the direct translation was rather poor. (That’s why I didn’t mention them in Last week Mohsen.) I’m sure it would be nice to have one-on-one conversations, but that never happens when you’re a tourist in a tourist area. Crosstalk is inevitable, and public announcements are often distorted, when seeing my very own no Italian face? Experienced retail and hospitality workers are usually mandatory Good morning And switched to English.

So, I wasn’t expecting much when my audio guide unceremoniously died ten minutes into my trip to the Sistine Chapel. If you saw a naked marble man…would you do it? needs To see how the next 20 miles over 1.86 miles are infinitely different? However, Meta specifically called for the use of AI glasses to place art in a museum context My experimental work. This was an opportunity to test it in the real world, away from the barriers of corporate demos.

It wasn’t perfect. In a certain marble bust, where he was Thin thread From LTE, Meta AI told me I was looking at Belvedere Torso. My signal stopped before she could explain anything else. However, I was relieved of my frustration with the labyrinthine design of the Vatican Museum. And if the Vatican were to one day invest in Wi-Fi (This will not happen, for security reasons), I can see this being a less complicated audio guide.

When my sister-in-law texted to ask if I was close to the church — her tour group left a half-hour before she let me in — I was happy that I could see her message, look me up, take a photo of the frescoed ceiling, and send a text message. It took three tries to send, but 15 minutes later, I got a text saying “Oh, you’re not close at all.”

But the real “fun” was recording short videos and recounting my experience which I later sent to a friend back home. Was I talking to myself in a low voice, earning the occasional sideways glance? Yes. Meanwhile, I kept my phone in my bag. I wasn’t watching all this great art through my phone like any other tourist standing between me and Michelangelo’s greatest works.

When I finally arrived at the Sistine Chapel, a guard shouted at me as I tried to use my phone’s camera to zoom in on the details. He learned that phones and photos, when he clicked on one of the signs, were prohibited in the church. fair enough. And he’s still the keeper He didn’t do that The hour I was wearing Meta glasses. I craned my neck back and spent 10 minutes using my glasses to zoom in and count as many of the angel’s expertly drawn butts as I could. It may seem strange to travel across an entire ocean and go through an entire maze only So. But Michelangelo was one of my mother’s favorite artists, and when I was a naughty kid in art museums, we made a game of counting Renaissance butts. (All things I’d rather die than explain to an angry museum guard.)

Part of me scolded myself for engaging in the kind of behavior I was worried about in my review. The other part of me laughed, because I had jet lag and, well, angelic butts. When it was time to leave, I felt comfortable taking the glasses off.

The Sistine Chapel experience, despite its flaws, was like a light bulb going on in my head. Although this technology has come a long way, smart glasses often don’t make sense to wear all day, every day. Battery life is very short. The glasses are too big, heavy, and cumbersome. But flaws don’t matter much when you wear them for a specific purpose for a limited time.

Navigate to Edge In the office, I feel afraid when recording video or taking photos. New York City’s grid system also makes sense, to the point where you don’t need AR walking directions. In my neighborhood or while going about my routine, I rarely have questions to ask Meta AI. But traveling to Italy, where I never knew how to get anywhere, and crossing the street is a deadly game of Frogger? These walking trends have changed the game. Whenever they reach a destination, they return to the shipping box.

Later, while touring the ruins of Pompeii, the glasses came in handy while listening to my lecturers. Tapping your fingers to take a photo is inherently less distracting. Sure, sometimes I have to pull out my phone to take a picture of a stray cat. But it didn’t escape my attention that whenever my phone went out, I was falling behind the group. Again, once the round was over, I took off my glasses and felt lighter for doing so.

The key was the freedom to put the glasses away.

Meta and other companies in this space often market these devices as general-purpose devices that can replace your phone. Maybe that will be true one day. but todayI was amazed at how the cultural misgivings I had were mitigated by associating it with a temporary use case. In Italy, whenever I put on the show glasses, I go into tourist mode. When I took them off, I was me again. It didn’t matter if things weren’t perfect, partly because it was just one of many travel tools I had in my arsenal.

Now that I’m home, I feel pressured to use glasses whether it makes sense or not. Partly for work, partly why do I have it if I’m not going to try to replace my phone?

But what if these tools don’t do it? He owns To inherit the mantle of smartphones, both generic in purpose and mass-market in appeal? What if we allowed them to be specific, specialized devices — “sometimes” tools that you might rent rather than own? You may rent tourist smart glasses from a travel agency before the trip, or your company will provide a pair if they are relevant to your business. Stadiums and concert venues may allow you to rent a pair for an event. Theaters and opera houses can use it to translate foreign works. When you’re done for the day, you go back to your phone.

This, of course, is a solution with its own set of problems. Long before Meta’s current consumer trend toward AI glasses, smart glasses makers turned to enterprises in the wake of Google Glass’ crash and burn. We live in late-stage capitalism, and this is arguably the most complicated and logistically nightmarish path to profitability. Some of these use cases It has already been exploredthe expense, lack of long-term commitment, price, and bulky hardware didn’t quite add up. Even if smart glasses are limited to these special use cases, it only takes one tech-savvy person to reopen the debate about the glass loophole and privacy.

However, it’s not lost on me that the most positive experience I’ve had with smart glasses was when they didn’t have to be a “do-it-all” device.