False positives create a dilemma for California inmates


A gloved hand points to a holding cell in the hospital ward of the Twin Towers prison in Los Angeles on April 16, 2020. About 3,000 inmates were recently transferred from jails to prisons, but on Thursday the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation suspended transfers again after a surge in coronavirus cases. Photo by Chris Carlson, AP Photo
A gloved hand points to a cell in the hospital ward of the Twin Towers prison in Los Angeles on April 16, 2020. Photo by Chris Carlson, AP Photo

If a drug test that could give a false positive result denied you parole, would you avoid entering a treatment program that required the drug test in the first place? Some California prison doctors say yes..

As CalMatters’ Cayla Mihalovich reports, about 50,000 California inmates have received drug addiction treatment since 2020. Treatment involves frequent presumptive drug tests to monitor recovery. Drug tests must not be used punitively, according to state correctional health services policy, a rule that mirrors standards set by the American Society of Addiction Medicine.

But the tests can also increase the chances of getting a false positive for substances other than prescription drugs. That can lead to inmates being denied parole and has discouraged some from entering treatment, prison doctors argued in a 2025 letter to the California parole board.

  • the letter: “Urine toxicology, like many medical tests, is imperfect. . . . We’ve personally had some of our most successful, stable patients test positive for substances they didn’t take because of false positives.”

Phil Stamps began drug treatment in 2020 at the San Quentin Rehabilitation Center to help end his opiate addiction. In a parole board review last year, commissioners cited six instances where he tested positive for methamphetamine between 2023 and 2025.

Stamps denied all of them and said he stopped taking antidepressants and one of his inhalers to reduce the chances of a false positive. A doctor also wrote in Stamps’ medical record that they were “convinced that (the patient) either had a lab mix-up or a false positive.”

Regardless, Stamps was denied parole and said he would like to never enter treatment.

  • Stamps: “The program can do a lot of good for people with substance use disorders, but because of what the parole board is doing, people are afraid to ask for help.”

Read more.


What should justice look like in California today? Join us in Los Angeles or virtually on February 25 for a conversation with Los Angeles District Attorney Nathan Hochman, former CDCR Director Dave Lewis and Heidi Rummel of the Post-Conviction Justice Project about prosecution, incarceration and whether reform or tougher policies will define the state’s future. Register here.



See the CA lawsuits against Trump in the CalMatters tracker

A man wearing a yellow hard hat and vest and gray pants stands next to a semi-truck as he signals with his left hand at a shipping terminal. The semi truck driver uses his side mirror to see what the other person is doing.
A hydrogen-powered gantry crane with rubber tires loads a shipping container on a semi-truck at the Port of Los Angeles in San Pedro on February 11, 2025. Photo by Joel Angel Juarez for CalMatters

California joins 12 Democratic-led states suing the Trump administration over clean energy funding cuts. At stake is about $2.7 billion in grants previously approved by Congress, $1.2 billion of which is earmarked for California alone.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta said Wednesday that almost all of that money for California was for finance hydrogen projectsa type of potentially clean fuel that is currently expensive to produce. Another $4 million, cut under President Donald Trump, was set aside for the state to implement energy-efficient building standards.

This is California’s 58th lawsuit against the federal administration since Trump’s return to the White House. In half of those cases, including this latest one, Trump is illegally “trying to be Congress,” Bonta said during a virtual news conference. He added that the state had protected about $200 billion in funding that Trump had tried to claw back.

For more on the other legal battles California is waging with Trump, see CalMatters case tracking tool.

The Democrats are getting ready to descend on SF

A projector shows a blue graphic of the California Democratic Convention, while people can be seen protesting in the foreground.
Protesters call for an Israeli ceasefire in Gaza at the California Democratic Convention in Sacramento on November 18, 2023. Photo by Miguel Gutierrez Jr., CalMatters

The The California Democratic State Convention begins Friday in San Francisco, kicking off a three-day meeting where some 3,500 expected Democratic delegates will choose who to endorse in the June primary, CalMatters’ Maya S. Miller and Jeanne Kuang write.

The race to succeed Gov. Gavin Newsom will be the biggest contest, although it is unlikely that any of the nearly 10 Democratic candidates will win enough delegates to win an official endorsement. Eight of those gubernatorial candidates are scheduled to give speeches at the convention on Saturday.

The convention will also highlight a dilemma the party has wrestled with since Trump’s second term: whether to continue supporting established congressional candidates backed by party leadership or to back political outsiders who have strong grassroots support.

There are signs of the desire for new candidates: In January, local delegates blocked five Democratic House incumbents from receiving endorsements that incumbents typically receive by default.

  • Heidi Halla Nevada county supervisor who is running for Congress: “People on the ground are tired of internal politics like this. They want to be heard and they want an opportunity to elect the candidate they want.”

Read more.

Finally: San Diego teachers call off strike

A group of people holding red and white signs stand on the grass in front of a school administration building. One of the main signs in the picture reads, "we can't wait for the future our students deserve."
Educators, families and community members gather outside the San Diego Unified School Board meeting in San Diego on January 27, 2026. Photo by Natalia Hamilton, San Diego Education Association

San Diego teachers reached an agreement with the San Diego Union School District on Friday, avoiding what would have been their first strike in 30 years. The new labor contract aims to provide more support for teachers in the specialty. Read more by Deborah Brennan of CalMatters.



Other things worth your time:

Some stories may require a subscription to read.


Newsom names new ones CPUC President Stirs Others // The Sacramento Bee

The red and blue states are the same want to limit AI in insurance. Trump wants to limit states // KFF Health News

Opponents of proposed CA wealth tax ramp up their campaign // A politician

A member of the Assembly of CA Valencia presents wasl to focus on suicide prevention among young men // EdSource

The Fresno area has a deadly history police car chases. When is persecution justified? // The Fresno Bee

Meta Launches $65 Million Election Push to advance AI program // New York Times

Tesla Will Stop Using the Term “Autopilot” to avoid 30 day suspension in CA // San Francisco Chronicle

Los Angeles revives zoning law which may prohibit some private detention centers from contracting with ICE // LAist

Women in California prison blame staff chef for rape and persistent accusations // The Guardian

Lynn La is a newsletter writer for CalMatters, which focuses on the top political, policy and Capitol stories in California each weekday. She produces and curates WhatMatters, CalMatters’ flagship daily newsletter…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *