Can CA protect its AI regulations from Trump’s executive order?


Close-up view of dark purple circular banners displayed at the top of a room full of conference attendees. Banners include text that says, "to quickly assess..." and "AI, data and…"
The Dreamforce conference, the world’s largest AI event according to Salesforce, hosted by Salesforce in San Francisco on September 18, 2024. Photo by Florence Middleton for CalMatters

This year, California lawmakers passed several measures regulating artificial intelligence. But President Donald Trump and Republicans in Congress are renewing efforts to block states from regulating the technology — potentially reversing those recent laws and sparking outrage from California officials.

The Trump administration last week released a draft executive order calling for a task force “whose sole responsibility” is to challenge state AI laws. Citing recent legislation passed by California and Colorado, the proposed order says the current regulatory framework allows “the most restrictive states to dictate national AI policy.” States found to be in violation of the order will have their federal funding withheld.

The project took off when Trump took it on social media to decry state “overregulation” of AI and advocate for “one federal standard.”

Meanwhile, Republican members of Congress are considering a provision in the National Defense Authorization Act, the annual military funding legislation, that would prevent state power from regulating AI. The offer prompted more than 200 state legislatorsincluding six Democrats from California, to burn a letter Monday opposes the idea.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta also urged congressional leaders to reject the proposed wording, arguing that the preemption would undermine states’ ability to respond “quickly and effectively to emerging technologies” and allow AI companies to “evade the protections of sound state law.” Thirty-two of the world’s 50 largest AI companies are located in California, according to Bonta’s office.

  • The letter: “Any federal AI law should serve as a threshold, not a ceiling, preserving flexibility for states to go further when necessary to protect their residents.”

The proposed executive order and bill wording are the latest in a series of federal moves to bar states from regulating AI after a failed effort earlier this year. In May, U.S. House Republicans proposed legislation that would have imposed a 10-year ban for states to enforce their AI lawsputting at risk 20 California state laws passed in 2024 US Senate ultimately rejected this measure in July after Democrats and a handful of state-rights Republicans denounced the bill.


CalMatters Events: Driven by the explosive growth of AI, data centers are power-hungry facilities that are reshaping the nation’s power landscape. CalMatters hosted an event in San Jose last week on how the state can balance the rapid growth of these centers with its clean energy goals. Catch the replay.



Will the CPUC Cut PG&E’s Profits?

Close-up of a PG&E bill on a patterned table showing a warning section highlighted in yellow. The notice lists past due amounts and a total balance of $400.68, with payment instructions and icons visible at the bottom of the page.
PG&E BILL ON NOV. 10, 2023. Photo by Manuel Orbegagoso for Calatters

California regulators next month will vote on a proposal to reduce the payout shareholders can receive from three major energy companies – a potential solution critics say won’t do enough to lower utility bills for millions of Californians, writes Malena Carollo of CalMatters.

Known as “return on equity,” this built-in expense in utility bills goes to shareholders for the risk of investing in utility companies. The California Public Utilities Commission is responsible for setting the state’s rate of return and is proposing to reduce that rate by 0.35% each for Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric.

If approved, profit margins for all three companies would shrink and shareholders would see a potential return next year of just under 10%. But critics also say that while the change could save millions of dollars for ratepayers across the state, it won’t mean much to people.

Read more here.

Listen: CalMatters special reports for your ear

Two people sit in the back of a jeep with the window open, one wearing an officer's uniform. Light shines from the open window onto the seated man wearing a CalMatters lanyard as the other man raises his hand to point as he speaks.
CalMatters reporter Sergio Olmos on a tour with Border Patrol agents from the El Centro Sector in Calexico on February 25, 2025. Photo by Kevin Clancy, Evident

Check out the latest radio work from CalMatters reporters:

  • Immigrant Raids: This fall, CalMatters teamed up with Latino USA to tell the story of Border Patrol Chief Gregory Bovino and the aggressive immigration raids he helped unleash across the country. This audio documentary features on-the-ground reports from Bakersfield, El Centro, Los Angeles, Chicago, and Mexico. We also spoke with elected leaders — including Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum, Gov. Gavin Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass — about their efforts to repel the attacks. Listen up English and in Spanish.
  • Deadly drivers: California, birthplace of Mothers Against Drunk Driving, now has some of the weakest DUI laws in the nation, according to new investigation by Robert Lewis and Lauren Hepler of CalMatters. This is the latest installment of CalMatters License to kill series about how California allows dangerous drivers to stay on the road even after they’ve killed people while driving. Listen as Robert discusses these new discoveries and the series as a whole Press Play on KCRW.
  • Helping Children Heal: Mi Escuelita is a preschool in San Diego dedicated to helping some of the youngest survivors of domestic violence heal. Hear CalMatters’ Adriana Heldiz share more about Mi Escuelita KPBS Roundtableand see how it moves visual essay about school.


Other things worth your time:

Some stories may require a subscription to read.


SNAP food benefits have resumedbut new work requirements could drive millions away from aid in CA // The Mercury News

Trump can’t take away California’s World Cup games. So why does he keep talking about it? // San Francisco Chronicle

SFPD on the offensive: SF police step up action to keep Trump at bay // The San Francisco Standard

Confronting Coal could push Oakland into bankruptcy // New York Times

Fresno Unified felt pressure from Trump to reduce DEI references, emails show // The Fresno Bee

Los Angeles’ overburdened homeless system left this family — with a 4-year-old — living in a car // LAist

This disabled mum survived the Eton fire. Now recovery is killing her // Los Angeles Times

San Diego County Sheriff’s Law Payouts jumped fivefold in just 10 years, data shows // San Diego Union Tribune

Lynn La is a newsletter writer for CalMatters, which focuses on the top political, policy and Capitol stories in California each weekday. She produces and curates WhatMatters, CalMatters’ flagship daily newsletter…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *